Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof

All-day liner that won't budge — creamy color that sets smudge-proof from morning to night.

Long-wearing, smudge- and water-resistant formula.
Glides on smoothly with rich, even color.
Built-in sharpener keeps a precise point.

$7.97

On Amazon when we checked (June 16, 2026) — live price may differ.

By Patrick Smith · Updated July 10, 2026 · How we review · We may earn a commission from Amazon links.

Price when checked: $7.97; on Amazon, June 16, 2026
Best for: People who prioritize wear time over creamy glide: long workdays, sensitive eyes,…
Biggest complaint: Removal takes real effort — plan on an oil-based cleanser or double cleansing.

Reasons to buy

All-day wear is the theme — 'stays in place all day' through work shifts, intense pigment, gentleness on sensitive eyes and with contacts, plus the convenience of the built-in sharpener at a drugstore price.

Reasons to skip

Removal takes real effort — plan on an oil-based cleanser or double cleansing.
The pencil can feel stiff and tug if applied cold, the built-in smudger is too hard for soft blending, the sharpener can break the tip, and a few buyers report batch-to-batch inconsistency.

Drugstore eyeliners usually fail in one of two ways: they glide on creamy and smear by lunch, or they stay put and feel like drawing with a crayon. The Revlon ColorStay pencil sits deliberately on the second side of that trade-off — long-term users consistently report it surviving 10-hour workdays without smudging, including sensitive-eyed and contact-lens wearers. The catch is built into the same formula: waterproof wear this stubborn needs an oil-based remover to come off, and the firm tip drags if you don't warm it up first on the back of your hand. Know those two things and it's one of the best few dollars in the makeup aisle.

What buyers say

Our summary of recurring themes in customer reviews on the Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof Amazon listing (read July 2026) — not quotes or endorsements.

Most praised

All-day wear is the theme — 'stays in place all day' through work shifts, intense pigment, gentleness on sensitive eyes and with contacts, plus the convenience of the built-in sharpener at a drugstore price.

Most common complaint

Removal takes real effort — plan on an oil-based cleanser or double cleansing. The pencil can feel stiff and tug if applied cold, the built-in smudger is too hard for soft blending, the sharpener can break the tip, and a few buyers report batch-to-batch inconsistency.

Worked best for

People who prioritize wear time over creamy glide: long workdays, sensitive eyes, contact-lens wearers. Worked worst for anyone wanting a soft, blendable smoky-eye pencil.

Frequently asked questions

Is Revlon ColorStay eyeliner waterproof?

Yes — it's formulated and reviewed as waterproof and smudge-proof, which is also why it needs an oil-based or dual-phase remover to take off cleanly.

Why does the pencil drag when I apply it?

The long-wear formula is firm by design. Warm the tip briefly on the back of your hand and it glides without tugging the lid — the trick most long-term users swear by.

Does it need a separate sharpener?

No — there's a sharpener built into the barrel. Sharpen gently (or chill the pencil first): pressing hard is the usual way the soft tip breaks.

Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof

$7.97 on Amazon when we checked (June 16, 2026). Amazon handles checkout, shipping and returns.

See price on Amazon →

More in Beauty & Personal Care

Related products we track in this category